PLA, PETG, ASA and TPU solve different problems. Start with where the part will live, what the printer can handle and the actual filament supplier’s instructions.
What load and temperature will the part see? Must it flex? Does the machine support the material? What finish, storage and ventilation does the spool require? No material label alone guarantees a safe or durable part.
MATERIAL / PLA
Start with a familiar profile
A common starting material for visual prototypes and general-purpose prints. A finished part’s performance still depends on temperature, load, geometry and print orientation.
Before printing: Check heat exposure and the exact spool profile.
Often used for functional parts where toughness and temperature behaviour matter. Surface adhesion can be strong, so check the sheet maker’s instructions.
Before printing: Check stringing, drying and build-surface compatibility.
For the same part, slice a candidate profile for each material. Record grams including supports and purge, print time, spool cost, likely setup and a stated failure allowance. A cheaper kilogram is not necessarily the cheapest usable part.
Fibre-filled composites may need wear-resistant hardware and have material-specific safety and handling requirements. Food contact, water tightness and structural suitability are not established by the polymer name.
For a first non-critical part, PLA is a useful starting point when the printer and chosen spool support it. Use the exact manufacturer profile and test the part for its intended conditions.
Is PETG always stronger than PLA?
No single strength claim covers every part. Material formulation, print orientation, layer bonding and loading all affect the result. Compare the actual application and test the part.
Can I use ASA without checking the environment?
No. ASA can warp and may release potentially harmful fumes. Check the printer and material maker’s instructions for enclosure and ventilation before deciding whether the setup is appropriate.
Why does wet filament matter?
Moisture can change print behaviour. Different polymers and spools need different handling; use the filament maker’s drying guidance and equipment limits rather than a universal temperature.
Do material and colour selections change the calculator’s costs?
No. They label the two scenarios visually. Enter the actual spool cost, slicer mass and other values yourself.